Princeton and Yale Played the First Thanksgiving Football Game in 1876, Before 1,000 Fans

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Thanksgiving football began on November 30, 1876, when Princeton met Yale in Hoboken, New Jersey, in the first college game ever played on the holiday. Fewer than 1,000 people watched, mostly students and alumni, as Yale won 2 to 0 in a contest that looked more like rugby.

Within a few years the matchup had become one of the biggest social events in New York. By 1893 it was drawing more than 50,000 fans and pulling families away from their own dinner tables.

A league built around one holiday game

The 1876 meeting came seven years after Princeton played Rutgers in what is considered the first college football game. The sport was still being worked out on campuses across the Northeast.

In 1873 students from Princeton, Yale, Harvard and Columbia formed the Intercollegiate Football Association. It standardized the rules and set the schedules, including a yearly Thanksgiving game in New York between the two teams with the best records from the season before.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Apart from Harvard in 1883 and 1887, those two teams were always Princeton and Yale. Through the 1880s and 1890s their holiday clash was the biggest date on the college football calendar.

From hundreds of fans to thousands

The real growth started in 1880, when the game moved across the Hudson River to the Polo Grounds in Manhattan. Crowds jumped from hundreds into the thousands, and 10,000 fans saw the 1881 game.

By the middle of the decade it was a fixture of New York society. A yearly game between Wesleyan and Pennsylvania was added as a side dish to the main course.

Test yourself

How much have you picked up so far?

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

3 quick questions on what you have read so far. The story continues below.

Champagne on the sideline

On the field, 1880s football was brutal, a game of mass tackles and flying wedges played by men with nothing thicker than skull caps on their heads. In the stands, the experience was surprisingly modern:

  • Vendors outside sold pennants and flags
  • Scalpers resold $1 tickets for $5
  • Bookmakers took cash bets from fans on the outcome

The crowd blazed with color. Princeton supporters wore orange and black, Yale backers wore blue, and fans tied handkerchiefs in team colors to umbrellas and walking sticks. Yale's female fans wore violets, while Princeton's wore yellow chrysanthemums and orange and black rosettes.

Some ticketholders parked their stagecoaches and carriages right beside the field for the ultimate tailgate. At the 1889 game at the Berkeley Oval in the Bronx, millionaire William K. Vanderbilt watched from his coach while drinking champagne from a goblet.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Princeton won that day 10 to 0 to finish an unbeaten season. Its quarterback, an All-America player, was named Edgar Allan Poe, and his father was a cousin of the famous writer.

Yale's 37 game streak

By 1890 teams had sprung up at colleges from coast to coast, and veterans of the Princeton and Yale rivalry, including Walter Camp and Amos Alonzo Stagg, did much to spread the game. That year 45 former Yale players and 35 former Princeton players were coaching around the country.

Yale opened the decade with a 37 game winning streak that included 36 shutouts. It began with a 32 to 0 rout of Princeton at Eastern Park in Brooklyn in 1890.

The next year Yale blanked Princeton 19 to 0 in pouring rain to cap a perfect season in which it outscored opponents 488 to 0. That game, at the newly opened Polo Grounds, drew 40,000 people, thousands of them watching from the rocky cliffs of Washington Heights.

College football becomes big business

The schools may have been amateurs, but the money was real. Each pocketed $340.42 from the 1880 game, and by 1891 that figure had passed $14,000.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Fans from across the country filled the best hotels on Fifth Avenue, and shops put team photographs and colors in their windows in the weeks before the game.

Long before Macy's sent balloons down the streets on Thanksgiving morning, Princeton and Yale fans held their own parade on the way uptown. Crowds stood three and four deep as carriages and omnibuses decorated in school colors carried fans blowing tin horns and bugles.

Also read: Macy's Thanksgiving Parade Drew 10,000 in 1924, and a Century of Balloons Followed

Churches moved their services for kickoff

The game changed the holiday itself. Churches across New York moved their Thanksgiving services earlier to avoid clashing with kickoff, and chairs sat empty at family dinners.

In 1891 Harper's Weekly declared that a powerful rival had taken the place of the Thanksgiving dinner, and that rival was the Thanksgiving game.

The last holiday showdown

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

After another Yale win in 1892, Princeton finally broke the streak in 1893, winning 6 to 0 in front of more than 50,000 fans. It turned out to be the rivals' last Thanksgiving meeting, although they played in the city for three more seasons, and in 1897 the game moved to their campuses.

The tradition they started outlived the rivalry's New York years. By the middle of the 1890s, colleges, high schools and club teams were playing about 5,000 games every Thanksgiving.

The New York Herald noticed the shift in 1893, observing that the day was no longer a solemn religious festival but a holiday granted to see a football game.

Also read: FDR Moved Thanksgiving Up a Week in 1939, and 23 States Refused to Follow

Based on reporting by History.com

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

By Trivia News Staff | Culture

Advertisement

Where to next?

Related articles

Violet Jessop Survived 3 Shipwrecks, Titanic Included, and 9 More Real Survivors

Violet Jessop lived through three of the most famous maritime disasters of the early 20th century, the Titanic...

Henry Ford Spent $20 Million on Fordlandia, a Midwest Town in the Amazon That Failed

Henry Ford poured about $20 million into Fordlandia, a Midwestern style company town he built in the Brazilian...

The White House Turkey Pardon Only Became Official in 1989, and Truman Never Gave One

The presidential turkey pardon only became an official White House custom on November 17, 1989, when George H.W....

The Edmund Fitzgerald Went Down With All 29 Aboard, 17 Miles Short of Shelter

On the evening of November 10, 1975, the freighter Edmund Fitzgerald vanished from radar in a Lake Superior...