The presidential turkey pardon only became an official White House custom on November 17, 1989, when George H.W. Bush spared a 50 pound bird in the Rose Garden. And Harry Truman, the president usually credited with starting it, never pardoned a turkey at all.
So the Thanksgiving ritual is younger, and a good deal messier, than most people assume. Here is how a holiday photo op slowly turned into a stay of execution.
The day Bush made it official
Bush picked a fitting year for it. 1989 marked two centuries since George Washington issued the first presidential proclamation of a day of public thanksgiving.
That November, Bush faced reporters, 30 schoolchildren and one restless 50 pound turkey. Handing a plump bird to the president before the holiday had been a photo opportunity since the 1940s, but Bush added something new.
The turkey, he observed, looked “understandably nervous.” Then he promised that this tom would not end up on anyone’s dinner table and announced that it had been granted a presidential pardon on the spot.
The ceremony has been held every year since. Bush made the tradition formal, though he was probably not the first president to let a turkey walk away.
A boy named Tad and a turkey named Jack
The earliest story goes back to Abraham Lincoln. His young son Tad is said to have grown attached to a turkey meant for the family’s Christmas dinner, named it Jack, and walked it around on a leash like a pet.
Tad begged his father to spare the bird, and Lincoln granted it a reprieve and let it go free.
About ten years later, under Ulysses S. Grant, a Rhode Island poultry dealer named Horace Vose began shipping fat turkeys to the White House for Thanksgiving. Vose was a firm Republican, but he sent birds to presidents of both parties until his death in 1913.
Test yourself
How much have you picked up so far?
3 quick questions on what you have read so far. The story continues below.
Enter the poultry industry
In 1946 two industry groups took over the job: the National Turkey Federation and the Poultry and Egg National Board. Their first delivery that year was a 42 pound Texas tom, presented to Truman for Christmas.
Truman did start appearing with the gift birds for staged photographs. That is probably why he is so widely, and wrongly, named as the father of the pardon.
The pardon Truman never gave
The confusion is common enough that the Truman Library put out a statement. Its staff said they had found no documents, speeches, clippings, photographs or other records of Truman pardoning the turkey he received in 1947, or any other year.
In fact, the birds given to Truman and several of the presidents after him went straight to the table:
- In 1948, Truman told reporters his turkeys "would come in handy" for the 25 guests expected at his home in Independence, Missouri, that Christmas
- In 1953, ten days before Thanksgiving, National Turkey Federation president Roscoe Hill handed Dwight Eisenhower a live 39 pound bird
- Eisenhower hoped Hill would kill and freeze it and send it back in time, because he planned to spend the holiday with his family and wanted to take it along
Also read: FDR Moved Thanksgiving Up a Week in 1939, and 23 States Refused to Follow
Kennedy lets one grow
The first president to take pity on a gift bird was John F. Kennedy in 1963. The turkey weighed 55 pounds and wore a sign around its neck, surely not by choice, reading "Good Eating, Mr. President!"
"We'll just let this one grow," Kennedy said with a smile, calling it his Thanksgiving present to the bird. That was November 19, 1963, and as the turkey headed back to a farm in California, Kennedy was preparing for his trip to Dallas three days later.
Newspapers reported that a "Merciful President Pardons Turkey," yet Kennedy never used the word himself.
Reagan's one word joke
The first president to actually say "pardon" at the ceremony may have been Ronald Reagan, and he meant it as a joke. In 1987, in the middle of the Iran-Contra affair, reporters pressed him on whether he would pardon any aides accused of wrongdoing.
He brushed the question off. When asked what would happen to the 55 pound turkey in front of him, he quipped, "I'll pardon him."
A short retirement
Today the National Thanksgiving Turkey and a backup bird, kept in case the first one does not survive to the ceremony, both receive a reprieve. Their freedom does not usually last long.
Turkeys bred for the table carry more weight than their skeletons and organs can support, so most pardoned birds die within a year.
Also read: What the Pilgrims Actually Ate at the First Thanksgiving in 1621
Based on reporting by History.com
By Trivia News Staff | Culture