A $3 New York Garage Sale Bowl Sold for $2.2 Million, and 20 Finds to Look For

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

In 2007 a New York family paid $3 at a local garage sale for what looked like a plain white glazed bowl. Six years later, once experts had worked out what it really was, the bowl went under the hammer at Sotheby’s in New York for $2.2 million.

The humble fruit bowl turned out to be a Chinese piece from the Northern Song Dynasty that had somehow come through more than 1,000 years in one piece. Nobody should expect that kind of luck on a Saturday morning, but neighborhood sales still turn up real bargains, and some categories are worth a closer look than others.

Art, Bakelite and books

Art. Skip the AI prints, paint-by-numbers kits and kitchen slogan plaques. Original work, even by little-known local artists, can be worth more than the sticker says, and there is always the slim chance of finding the real thing.

Bakelite. One of the first synthetic plastics, Bakelite was used in the 1920s and 1930s for radios, kitchenware, jewelry and toys. Nobody makes it anymore, so the supply is fixed and collectors pay well for good pieces. To spot it, look for aged plastic with a smooth surface that makes a woody sound when tapped and gives off a faint whiff of formaldehyde, a leftover from how it was made.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Books. Most paperbacks fetch a dollar or two, but a valuable title can hide in the pile. First editions and signed copies are the obvious prizes, and pre-1950s books that still have their dust jackets are worth checking too.

Cameras, cast iron and ceramics

Cameras. Millennials and Gen Z have fallen for film photography, and old cameras have jumped in value. Working models from big names like Leica and Canon can be worth hundreds of dollars.

Cast iron. As cooks move away from plastic and chemical nonstick coatings, old cast iron pans are back in fashion. A little tarnish should not put you off, since cast iron cleans up with some elbow grease.

Ceramics. Experts use the acronym RADAR, for rarity, aesthetics, desirability, authenticity and really good condition. Watch for damage, because even a small chip or crack can cut the value in half.

Test yourself

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

How much have you picked up so far?

3 quick questions on what you have read so far. The story continues below.

Clothing, comics and costume jewelry

Clothing. Big labels are always worth a look. A $1.50 clutch bag picked up at a thrift store was later valued at $35,000 after it turned out to be a rare Cartier Art Deco piece, and even Levi's jeans made before 2000 can be worth something now.

Comic books. In 2024 a rare copy of Action Comics No. 1, the first Superman comic, sold at auction for a record $6 million. You will not find that at a garage sale, but comics from the Golden Age of 1938 to 1956 and the Silver Age of 1956 to 1970 deserve a second look.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Also read: A Teenie Beanie Baby From a Happy Meal Sold for $1,799, and 7 More Toys Worth Money

Costume jewelry. Sellers often price it at a few cents or a dollar a piece, or sell it by the boxful. Dig through those boxes, since signed pieces, brooches by major makers and real precious metal sometimes turn up in the mix.

Jadeite, old electronics and band shirts

Jadeite. This milky green glassware was the height of fashion in the 1930s and 1940s and stayed in production into the 1970s. It is a hot retro collectible today, though scratches, chips and cracks drag the price down sharply.

Old electronics. More than 100 million Nintendo Game Boys were sold, but one still in its original box with all the extras is rare. Working handsets can bring hundreds of dollars, and old game cartridges, early consoles and graphics cards can pay off too.

Merchandise. Bands go in and out of fashion, so old concert programs and T-shirts drift into garage sales. Depending on the act, the age and the condition, some classic band shirts from the 1980s and 1990s now sell for thousands.

Pyrex, sports cards and sterling silver

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Pyrex. A full set might bring a few hundred dollars and a single dish a few dozen. Certain patterns and colors are worth thousands to collectors, so look for the vintage all-capital "PYREX" label rather than the modern lowercase one.

Sports cards. Age, rarity and star players drive value, and a few vintage cards are worth millions. Garage sale finds will be humbler, but valuable single cards and complete sets do appear.

Sterling silver. Real silverware can hide in a box of old cutlery. Look for "STERLING," "STER" or a purity mark above 900, and note that "EP" or "EPNS" means electroplated nickel silver, which is worth far less.

Teddy bears, tools and uranium glass

Teddy bears. In 2003 a bear bought for £130, about $275 today, at a boot sale in Wales turned out to be a 1905 Steiff and was valued at £4,000 to £6,000, roughly $10,000 to $15,000. Steiff bears usually carry a metal button in the fur of one ear.

Tools. Garage sales are a cheap source of working tools, and collectors prize postwar Craftsman tools from the 1940s and 1950s. Complete modern sets of screwdrivers or drill bits can be worth hundreds as well.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Uranium glass. Small pieces sell for around $40 or $50, while larger or unusual ones reach the hundreds. Kitchenware is common, so the rarer finds tend to be ornaments, vases, lamp bases and candlesticks.

Vintage toys and vinyl records

Vintage toys. Original Barbie dolls, G.I. Joes, Star Wars figures and Masters of the Universe toys always draw collectors, especially in good condition with their original packaging.

Vinyl records. Physical music is making a comeback, and original pressings of classic albums are worth more than ever. The biggest names command the highest prices, but how well the record plays and the state of its cardboard sleeve matter just as much.

Also read: Blockbuster Had 9,000 U.S. Stores in 2004, Then Laughed Netflix Out of the Room

So the next time a hand-lettered sign points down a driveway, it may be worth pulling over. The odds of a $2.2 million bowl are tiny, but the categories above are where the real finds tend to hide.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Based on reporting by Mental Floss

By Trivia News Staff | Culture

Advertisement

Where to next?

Related articles

France Has 12 Time Zones, One More Than Russia or the United States

The country with the most time zones in the world is not Russia, the United States or China....

Wojtek the Bear Was Enlisted as a Polish Soldier in WWII and Carried Artillery Shells

During World War II, one unit of the Polish army picked up a recruit unlike any other: a...

Colonial Williamsburg Has Nearly 500 Buildings, and 4 More Living History Museums

Colonial Williamsburg covers 301 acres and holds nearly 500 structures, from taverns and merchant shops to privies and...

Yuengling Has Brewed Beer in Pennsylvania Since 1829, and 6 More Old U.S. Breweries

America's oldest working brewery opened in 1829 in Pottsville, Pennsylvania, when a 23-year-old German immigrant named David G....