Black Friday Began as a Philadelphia Police Gripe in the 1950s, Not a Retail Win

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Black Friday did not get its name from stores finally turning a profit. In the 1950s, Philadelphia police officers used it to describe the day after Thanksgiving, when crowds of shoppers and tourists jammed the city and nobody on the force got the day off.

The cheerful version most Americans learned came decades later, and it was largely a retail invention. The real story starts even earlier, on Wall Street, with a gold scheme that went badly wrong.

The first Black Friday had nothing to do with shopping

The earliest recorded use of the phrase points to a financial disaster. On September 24, 1869, the U.S. gold market crashed.

Two famously ruthless financiers, Jay Gould and Jim Fisk, had spent weeks buying up as much of the country’s gold as they could. Their plan was to push the price sky high and then sell at an enormous profit.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

On that Friday the plot fell apart. The stock market went into free fall, and the losses reached everyone from Wall Street tycoons to ordinary farmers.

The story stores like to tell

The explanation you hear most often goes like this. Retailers supposedly ran at a loss, or “in the red,” for most of the year, then moved “into the black” the day after Thanksgiving as holiday shoppers spent freely on discounted goods.

Stores really did record losses in red ink and profits in black. But as an origin story for the shopping day, this officially approved version is simply not accurate.

A darker myth has spread more recently, claiming that Southern plantation owners in the 1800s could buy enslaved people at a discount the day after Thanksgiving. That claim has led some people to call for a boycott of the shopping day, yet there is no historical basis for it at all.

Test yourself

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

How much have you picked up so far?

3 quick questions on what you have read so far. The story continues below.

What really happened in Philadelphia

The true origin is less flattering to retailers. Every year, the day after Thanksgiving brought hordes of suburban shoppers and visitors into Philadelphia ahead of the Army-Navy football game, which was played in the city that Saturday.

For the police, it was a miserable shift. Officers could not take the day off and had to work extra-long hours handling the crowds and traffic, while shoplifters took advantage of the chaos inside packed stores.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

By 1961 the name had stuck so firmly in Philadelphia that local merchants and boosters tried to rebrand it as "Big Friday." The effort failed. Even so, the term stayed mostly local for years, and as late as 1985 it still was not in common use across the country.

How retailers turned it around

Sometime in the late 1980s, retailers found a way to make the name work in their favor. They leaned into the "red to black" idea, presenting the day as the moment America's stores finally made their money for the year.

That version caught on, and the Philadelphia roots faded from memory. By the 1990s Black Friday had grown into a shopping event recognized around the world.

Also read: Macy's Thanksgiving Parade Drew 10,000 in 1924, and a Century of Balloons Followed

A century of holiday shopping milestones

Black Friday sits inside a longer American story of retailers and the holiday calendar:

  • Macy's held its first parade in 1924 as a "Christmas Parade" on Thanksgiving Day, with zoo animals, and balloons did not appear until 1927
  • In 1939 President Franklin D. Roosevelt moved Thanksgiving up a week to give shoppers more time, a change critics nicknamed "Franksgiving," and in 1941 Congress fixed the holiday on the fourth Thursday of November
  • Cyber Monday arrived in the 2000s as online shopping took off, and by 2017 Americans were spending $6.6 billion online on that single day
  • American Express launched Small Business Saturday in 2010, and by 2015 some 95 million shoppers spent $16.2 billion at small businesses on it

The bargains have come with a cost

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The rush for deals has not always been harmless. Fights and stampedes have broken out at store openings, and since 2006 there have been 10 deaths and 111 injuries recorded nationwide on Black Friday.

Meanwhile the one-day sale has stretched into a four-day event, with Small Business Saturday and Sunday, Buy Nothing Day and Cyber Monday all following in its wake. Stores also kept opening earlier, so the most determined shoppers can now head out as soon as Thanksgiving dinner is over.

Also read: Sears Ran More Than 700 Stores by the 1950s, Then the Department Store Lost Its Crown

So the next time a store promises that Black Friday is when it finally gets into the black, you will know the name actually came from tired Philadelphia police officers stuck working through the holiday weekend.

Based on reporting by History.com

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

By Trivia News Staff | Culture

Advertisement

Where to next?

Related articles

The Bermuda Triangle Got Its Name From a 1964 Magazine Story, and NOAA Sees No Mystery

The Bermuda Triangle was not named by sailors or pilots. The name, and the idea that the area...

Blockbuster Had 9,000 U.S. Stores in 2004, Then Laughed Netflix Out of the Room

In 2004 there were more than 9,000 Blockbuster Video stores across the United States, each packing some 6,000...

Rockefeller’s Trust Controlled 90% of U.S. Oil Refining, and 8 More Robber Barons

By 1882, John D. Rockefeller's Standard Oil Trust controlled 90% of America's oil refineries and pipelines. He was...

Sylvan Goldman’s 1937 Shopping Cart Was Mocked Until He Hired Actors to Push It

When Sylvan N. Goldman rolled out his first shopping cart at an Oklahoma City supermarket in 1937, shoppers...