In 1705 a Connecticut Town Delayed Thanksgiving a Week Over Pumpkin Pie

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

In 1705 the town of Colchester, Connecticut, pushed its Thanksgiving back a full week because it did not have enough molasses to make pumpkin pie. That is how seriously New Englanders were already taking the dessert, more than 150 years before Thanksgiving became a national holiday.

Few holiday foods have deeper American roots. The story of the pie runs from ancient Central American farms to English kitchens, abolitionist novels and, finally, a can from Chicago.

From Central America to England and back

Pumpkins were first grown in Central America around 5,500 B.C. They were among the earliest foods European explorers carried home from the New World, with the first mention in Europe dating to 1536.

Within a few decades the English were growing them regularly and calling them “pumpions,” from the French “pompon,” a nod to their round shape. They slipped easily into England’s long tradition of sweet and savory stuffed pastries.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

So when the Pilgrims sailed on the Mayflower in 1620, some of them probably knew pumpkins about as well as the Wampanoag, who helped them through their first year at Plymouth Colony.

Was it at the first Thanksgiving?

A year later, the 50 surviving colonists were joined by a group of 90 Wampanoag for a three day harvest celebration. Pumpkin was likely on the table in some form.

The squash was handy, especially for making bread without much flour, but it was not always loved. In 1654 Massachusetts ship captain Edward Johnson noted that as New England grew richer, people were baking apple, pear and quince tarts “instead of their former Pumpkin Pies.”

Test yourself

How much have you picked up so far?

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

3 quick questions on what you have read so far. The story continues below.

Early pies looked nothing like ours

Those "former" pies came in many forms, and only a few would look familiar today:

  • A 1653 French cookbook told cooks to boil pumpkin in milk and strain it before putting it in a crust
  • Hannah Woolley's 1670 Gentlewoman's Companion layered pumpkin with apple and seasoned it with rosemary, sweet marjoram and a handful of thyme
  • An early New England recipe skipped the crust entirely, filling a hollowed pumpkin with spiced, sweetened milk and cooking it right in the fire
  • An English version of that shell method stuffed the pumpkin with sliced apples instead

By the early 1700s the pie had won its place as Thanksgiving grew into an important New England holiday, which is how Colchester ended up waiting a week for molasses. Amelia Simmons's pioneering American Cookery of 1796 included two pumpkin pie recipes, one close to the custard version we eat today.

Also read: What the Pilgrims Actually Ate at the First Thanksgiving in 1621

The dessert of the abolitionists

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

In the mid 1800s pumpkin pie picked up an unlikely political meaning. Many of the most committed abolitionists came from New England, and their favorite dessert started appearing in their novels, poems and broadsides.

Sarah Josepha Hale, the editor who spent decades campaigning for a national Thanksgiving, put it in her 1827 anti-slavery novel Northwood. Her holiday table was crowded with desserts, "yet the pumpkin pie occupied the most distinguished niche."

In 1842 abolitionist Lydia Maria Child wrote her famous poem about a New England Thanksgiving. It opens with "Over the river, and through the wood" and ends by cheering for the pumpkin pie.

Yankee food in the South

When Abraham Lincoln made Thanksgiving a national holiday in 1863, many in the Confederacy read it as an attempt to force Yankee customs on the South. One editorial writer in Richmond, Virginia, mocked the holiday as a Yankee ritual of devout offerings to themselves of pumpkin pie and roast turkey.

After the Civil War, Thanksgiving and its pie spread across the country, helped along by women's magazines like the one Hale edited.

The can that changed everything

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

In 1929 Libby's, a meat canning company in Chicago, launched a line of canned pumpkin. It quickly became a Thanksgiving fixture of its own and spared cooks from roasting and straining their own squash.

So the can on your counter this month carries a long line behind it, from Mesoamerican farmers and English pie makers to New England reformers and a Chicago canner.

Also read: Colonial Williamsburg Breakfast Was Cornmeal Hoecakes, Not Today's Pancake Stacks

Based on reporting by History.com

By Trivia News Staff | Culture

Advertisement

Where to next?

Related articles

Franklin’s Arctic Expedition Lost All 129 Men, While All 28 of Shackleton’s Survived

Sir John Franklin's 1845 Arctic expedition ended with every one of its 129 men dead. Seventy years later,...

Robert Wadlow of Illinois Stood 8 Feet 11 Inches and Is Still the Tallest Man Ever

Robert Wadlow, from Alton, Illinois, measured 8 feet, 11.1 inches when he died in 1940 at just 22....

A Teenie Beanie Baby From a Happy Meal Sold for $1,799, and 7 More Toys Worth Money

One Teenie Beanie Baby that came free with a McDonald's Happy Meal sold for $1,799 on eBay, all...

Sarah Josepha Hale Lobbied for 30 Years Before Lincoln Made Thanksgiving National

Abraham Lincoln signed the 1863 proclamation that made Thanksgiving a national holiday, and William Seward drafted it. But...